Tuesday, October 28, 2008

A Better Way to Study Kanji (1)

There's a million ways out there to learn kanji. Some people will tell you to throw a poster up on the bathroom wall and study whenever it's "convenient" while others focus on the importance of mnemonic devices. As for myself, I've often taken the "hard" road and opted for the brute-force method of rinse and repeat. As far back as my high school study days, I spent a lot of time writing out characters. I started with hiragana and katakana. I wrote and I wrote. Then I wrote some more. And you know what--it worked! I had the kana down pretty quick.

Then comes the behemoth-like enigma known as kanji. It sends chills running down the spine of many a student of Japanese and is the source of great controversy when it comes to learning methods. My six years in Japan (and 14 years studying the language) have taught me one thing about kanji: you can't learn them in a vacuum. This should come as common sense to most people who have spent a lot of time with the language. Kanji didn't pop out of nowhere. It's changed and grown along with the spoken language and the rest of the written language. Some characters come straight from China. Some have undergone some changes. Some were made right here in good ol' Nippon, too.

One thing I've always kept in mind is the components that make up a kanji character. With thousands upon thousands of characters to learn, the number may as well be infinite. But the components, my friends, are much more finite. They're also a lot easier to remember.

Let's look at a few characters. Some you may know. Some you may not.
設 投 股

At a glance, they might look a bunch of random characters tossed together. Many students of Japanese might approach these characters one by one, trying to remember them like "Okay, so first I draw four horizontal lines...then a square...then this hump sort of thing followed by a couple strokes that look like a table." Frankly, it's going to be pretty hard to tackle a few thousand (or even a few hundred) characters like that.

A closer look (at the right side) will show that they all have something in common: a ル on top of a 又(また). This little guy has a name, and not surprisingly, it's called るまた.

Did a spark go off yet? Now that you've got a name for part of the kanji, you can file that in your brain. るまた= ル on top of 又. That's a lot easier to remember than the above mess, right? Just categorize these pieces the same way you do あ(the character)=あ(the sound). It's easier than you think.

But where do I get started? How do I learn the names for all these pieces? Well a good place to start is a site like this or this that has a list of radicals. (If neither of those sites meet your fancy, just trying googling 部首 and 一覧 and see what pops up.)

Radicals, or 部首 in Japanese, are the components of a character that are traditionally used to classify them in dictionaries. Knowing the different radicals will give you a good working knowledge of the components that are out there to learn. For example, the below characters all share the common radical.

汗 泳 消 海 油

The radical is called sanzui and is the first three strokes on the left side. Just being able to recognize that this is a common component (and one that has its very own name!) will help expedite learning and systematize memorization.

Look forward to more on radicals, and other kanji components, in upcoming articles!

13 comments:

BlueCheese said...

Good post, I only know maybe 150 kanji so far. Up till now I have learnt them by repetition, entering them in a flashcard program along with the readings. Then adding compounds with the reading and meaning on the other side. I use my DS to write the answer when a card comes up.

It has worked for me so far but I definitely think doing the same thing for the radicals will help massively. So thanks.

Robinson Mussu said...

This is pretty close to how I've been trying to tackle groups of new kanji lately. However, instead of associating kanji with the names of their components, I've tried to benefit from the "rhyming" or phonetic-signific principle by which a lot of kanji were coined and associate the applicable component with its on reading.

For example, there's 寺 ('temple') with the on'yomi "ji"; then we have 時 ('time, hour'), something to do with time (the 日 part) and an on'yomi like 寺. Then there's 持 ('hold, have'), relating to hands (手) and read similarly, and 詩, in the domain of words (言), read somewhat like 寺 ("shi" this time around), etc.

Of course, this doesn't always work quite so neatly. Sometimes there can be distinct subgroups differing in their on'yomi — 設,殺 vs. 役,疫; 限,銀 vs. 根,恨 — and sometimes either component can be a bit of a stretch (e.g. sound change and simplification can have mystifying effects). But even so, I've found this to be a great help in acquiring new kanji and associating them with ones learned previously. [Apologies if this stuff has been covered here before.]

Chris said...

robinson,
Thank you for your sound analysis! That's actually something I hope to cover in an upcoming article. Thank you for giving readers a preview! ;)

John said...

Thanks for the post, I'm glad your still around (I was getting a little worried). Will you be posting an update on current kanji learning games or do your previous recommendations still hold true?

Chris said...

john,
I'm still keeping my eyes out there on software as it comes out, but there's not much new these days. Nothing worth reporting on at least. Maybe when Rocket Company gets Kanken DS 3 out. ;)

I've got to figure out some other kanji-related material besides games to keep things rolling I think.

天然パーマンTENNEN PARMAN [from Japan] said...

Hi, I am Tennen-Perman,E-mail from Japan.
I visited your site sometimes so far.
You have a cool site.
I linked your site in my blog.
I administer a blog talking about cooking.
Please link to my site in your ones if you like it.

http://impact-cook.blogspot.com/

thank you!

Anonymous said...

Just wanted to say I like your articles, especially the ones about the games for learning Japanese. Kanken 2 has been such a great help.
I hope you post articles more often.

Jeff said...

Good to see this blog is still alive.

...and even better to see somebody giving tips on kanji study methods that amount to more than just "do Heisig".

I've referred some people I know who are interested in studying-by-DS to your site over the last year, because I know it certainly kick-started my DS studying habits which have been extremely beneficial in kanji learning/practice. Keep up the good work!

Al said...

Nowpro is coming out with a new DS game. I hope you review it.

indiana jones said...

good post....
can i speak japan language easy or is there easy way to learn it?

Harvey said...

Could you guys do a review of this game for Chinese?

http://www.gakken.co.jp/dc/ds/chinese/mode/index.html

made by the kanken people!

Billy said...

Very informative post for the beginner. I'm having a hard time getting to the next level and taking a step backwards to get a grip on the learning process once more might be exactly what I need.

Surrealus said...

Heard of Kanji Damage? http://www.hellodamage.com/kanjidicks/main.htm

KD takes the radicals to another level by adding non-traditional 'radicals' and using them - changing the definition to "symbols that are used as radicals in three or more (common) kanji". This seems like a very big advancement to me and just makes more sense; further removing itself from the old-school Japanese teaching. Everyone ought to be using it.

(however, I'm still not sure about using the KD method full out because it seems to have a flaw in that it uses english mnemonics all the way through. still has a lot of break-through ideas though)