Wednesday, October 10, 2007

Kanken DS 2 Review

I should have known that the only way for kanji software to surpass Kanken DS was for Rocket Company to tag a "2" on the end and release a sequel. They managed to take everything that worked in the first game, and combined it with a few polishes to create a masterful title that is an invaluable study tool.

The main feature of the game is in preparing users to take the official Kanji Kentei, a test taken by millions of people in Japan and worldwide. The test is covered in the game by taking mock tests or reviewing sample questions.

There are two types of mock tests, a 15 minute quick test, and a 60 minute test that reflects the exact format of the real examination. These tests are great for gauging your ability within a certain level and fantastic practice if you plan on sitting the test in the future. The 15 minute test is useful if you're just going to kill some time on the train or when you want to take a break from work or other studying. The 60 minute version is a good "test-drive" before taking the official test as the scoring, format, and time limit are exactly the same. Unlike the original, Kanken DS 2 allows you to take any test at any time. This means you can not only test your knowledge of the basics but can also take a peek at the higher levels and more difficult questions.

When you're done testing your level, you can review old or new material via a huge selection of sample questions. These questions are split up by Kanken level and by topic. These topics include 読み取り(reading), 書き取り(writing)、部首(radicals), 音訓(on/kun reading), and more. While these are the same problems that appear in the tests mentioned above, these problems allow you to practice in sets. Say you want a set of reading problems from level 5. All you have to do is select "level 5" and then "reading". Once you've finished, you can check your score before heading on to your next set of questions. One of Kanken DS 2's best features comes up here. Any problems that you miss during a review set are stored by the game, allowing you to try them again at any time. They'll stay stored until you get them right, too, which is great for those tricky questions that you keep on missing again and again.

Sometimes I like to re-take the questions I miss immediately, but it's great to have the option of knowing I can go back a week later on a set of questions I totally bombed on, and check to see if I've made an improvement.

Kanken DS 2's biggest improvement is the inclusion of a kanji dictionary featuring the 1945 joyo kanji . You can access the dictionary from the main menu allowing you to search for a character by writing the kanji or the reading. The other awesome feature is that you can view the relevant dictionary entries whenever you miss a problem during a practice test or sample question set. This lets you immediately review a kanji or two (in the case of a compound) that you failed to answer correctly. The dictionary allows you to check the readings, radicals, stroke counts, and stroke orders of all the joyo kanji. Even though the dictionary doesn't contain definitions for the characters, it's still a fantastic tool for reviewing most of the information the Kanken tests you on.

When you're done testing and going through sets of problems, you can also relax with a generous collection of kanji-based games. The games give you a chance to show off your kanji prowess in a variety of challenges revolving around reading, writing, stroke order, radicals, and more. The radical game features ninjas. If that doesn't convince you to pick up the game, I don't know what will. There's also three games to unlock, adding to the fun.

The game also keeps track of your progress as you advance in levels and tackle each of the 44,000 problems featured on the game card. You can check how many problems you've cleared or how you're faring in the different testing areas at each level. In the first Kanken DS, your stats seemed to reset every now and then, rendering the feature useless. Luckily Kanken DS 2 picked up on the problem and always gives you an up-to-date, overall report.

I should also mention that input recognition is fabulous. It's probably one of the most accurate pieces of software on the DS. I have almost no problems inputting hiragana, katakana, or kanji. Almost any time the game detects the wrong character, it's a mistake on my part. Just be sure to watch your stroke order with the kanji! Writing out a character, no matter how perfectly, with the wrong stroke order will baffle the software. Some people complain about this, but I think it's a great way of forcing learners to buckle down and learn the stroke order--it's important.

The game is wrapped up in consistent production values and (fairly) decent music, making Kanken DS 2 a fantastic title all around. If you're looking for software to test your kanji skills from start to finish, then you're going to want to pick up this title.

And did I mention the kanji game featuring ninjas?

Pick up your copy here at Amazon.

20 comments:

girasol said...

Hi there! As an advanced learner of Japanese, I enjoy reading your blog and finding out about new studying material :]

I have a question about Kanken DS2 - is it worth getting even if you already own the first? I got the first one not too long ago, but I'm wondering if there's a point to getting both? Thanks!!

Coal said...

Given the price, I would say yes (I have both).


Gonna have to disagree on the music. It's godawful and distracting to the point I had to switch the volume off in the middle of a test (which made the game a little less friendly without the feedback sounds). I'd say the best thing about the music is the option not to have any.

Chris said...

>girasol

Since the game is quite inexpensive (around 2700 yen), there's no reason not to pick up Kanken DS 2. The additional dictionary feature and advanced level questions, as well as the excellent input detection definitely make it worth it.

>coal

I don't think music option #2 is so bad. ;)

Coal said...

#2 is vaguely tolerable. I made the mistake of "trying out" #3 last night for a one hour test, and after just 10 minutes it had driven me to distraction. The ninja music is very cool though! ;-)

Incidentally, out of the 3 unlockable games, I've so far got one - a kanji shiritori game which is surprisingly hard. Not a scratch on Sushi-damacy mind...

A. Reader said...

Nice review.

I agree that it's better than the first one, but it's still not perfect. I wish there was a way to review a wrong answers after taking a test and I think there should also be an option as to whether you get the answer straight away or not- that can make a lot of difference to the test. Really I wish it was a bit more like a paper test.

Ideally there would also be a dictionary included, but then it would be a dictionary with a kanji test rather than the other way round. Will just have to keep one handy!

All in all a nice bit of software for a very low price.

achikochi said...

As always, thank you for the eternally helpful reviews. I am an intermediate level student with a somewhat lagging level of kanji proficiency. I got the first Kanken software while in Japan and it was a bit to hard for me.

With the new additions to this sequel is it more approachable for a non advanced student?

Chris said...

achikochi,

While the new features are useful, I don't think they make the software much easier than Kanken DS unfortunately.

Though I do find the games a bit easier in the second installment.

Coal said...

Just unlocked the second game, which I think is this title's 鮨魂 - you have to correctly read place names from around the world from their kanji. It's multiple choice and it doesn't just end when you get one wrong, but pretty fun and useful nonetheless.

UNSQUARED [(Un)^2] said...

This sounds pretty awesome. Sounds like it'd be good to pick up.

Question: How much Japanese would you need to know for this to be of any use? I'm in my second year, btw.

Chris said...

UNSQUARED,

Thank you for your comment.

I would say that the software is useful if you know about 600 or more kanji. If you know too much less,then you'll end up stuck scrolling through the menus and getting confused about things besides the questions at hand.

Harvey said...

I so need to go pick up a DS Lite and get this thing.

I keep telling myself I'm going to, but I just never get into the store! I will I will.

Amer Zeni said...

I want to buy this but I am confused by the price. Why is it cheaper than game 1 - I mean why the heck does that make sense? And what is the difference between the different versions of game 1?

Chris said...

Amer,

Kanken DS 2 has more content than its prequel. It covers more levels of the test nad has loads of questions and some great minigames. It also has a useful dictionary.

I'm not exactly sure why it has a lower price than Kanken DS, though. You'd have to ask Rocket Company.

nicocoer said...

Hi there. I'm a fairly new learner but I'm better with translations than the current practices focus on.

My big question is if it does indeed have the capability for competing with another person, or if my glance over the Amazon pages is entirely inaccurate.

If it's accurate, then I might actually be picking this up with a friend of mine or having the Japanese club at his school pick up a copy or two. After getting through the basics, it seems like this would be an excellent next step, and certainly better than spilling flashcards all over the floor of the city bus.

(In the end, I might just get it for the dictionary, as mine doesn't do stroke order or anything and is entirely too confusing. Gosh, the DS has so many capabilities and possibilities that it's making me bounce about with geek-y glee.)

avparker said...

I have the first Kanken, it's great to test your level, but I found the minigames to be useless. You mention it's a bit better in this one, but I'd like to clarify.

Do the minigames take your level into account? I'm level 9 so it's pretty important.

Are the minigames actually useful for learning new Kanji?
In Kanken 1 they gave no feedback when you got it wrong (even worse than the test!).


I'm going to get なぞっておぼえる大人の漢字練習 完全版, but am also considering updating to Kanken 2, especially if the games are better.

Chris said...

>My big question is if it does indeed have the capability for competing with another person

Kanken 2 is for one player only.

>Do the minigames take your level into account? I'm level 9 so it's pretty important.

Unfortunately the minigames don't take your level into consideration in Kanken 2 either. You'll probably find the new games similar to the old ones.

It would be great if they could scale the questions so that they varied based on the level. Hopefully they'll incorporate something like that into future titles!

Estella said...

Thank you for your review! I think this will definitely be something that I'd add to my Japanese study materials :) Do you by any chance know if there are Jap games that help with JLPT study?

Anonymous said...

The reviews on the Amazon Japan site mentions something about a bug that the game has and that it freezes. Have you found that at all in your experience?

Dr. Doyle said...

I have been studying with Kanken DS2 for about a year and a half straight. I have spent countless hours on it. I have never had it freeze up on me.

As "a. reader" said, I want them to come out with Kanken DS3, with an option to go straight through the tests, and to review wrong answers after the actual tests just like you can review on the practices until you get them right. I want this more than ANYTHING. "Do it."

Al said...

I have some more screenshots and comments here.